29 Comments
User's avatar
Dikla Marshall's avatar

Batya, do you have any thoughts on Megyn Kelly? She has really disappointed me. She was an avid supporter of Israel, and now she seems to speak with such disdain. It pains me.

Diana Murray's avatar

The Republicans are purging antisemites, how?

J.D. Vance is joined at the hip to Tucker Carlson.

Steven S. Lamb's avatar

Vance is not going to be the 2028 nominee. He is done

Diana Murray's avatar

Who do you think it will be?

honest question, not trolling.

Diana Murray's avatar

I really doubt that. But we’ll see.

H.S.'s avatar

Republicans will not win in ‘28. And Israel is only a burden in 28, not a plus. Nobody will exclude an anti-Israel candidate In GOP primaries.

H.S.'s avatar

Republicans will not win in ‘28. And Israel is only a burden in 28, not a plus. Nobody will exclude an anti-Israel candidate

Three Big Lies's avatar

If JD doesn’t call out Tucker, his political career will end with this administration. IMHO.

Diana Murray's avatar

I'm not so sure. We'll see, won't we?

Steven Brizel's avatar

The Democrats have completed their long march to the far left which began in the aftermath of their defeat in 1968 They will remain in a deserved desert of their making unless and until moderates regain control of that party

Sandra Pinches's avatar

I see no sign of moderates reversing the trend. The Democratic Party has been transformed into an entirely different entity, and not enough is left of the original party to resurrect at this point.

Bill H's avatar

To all of the Democrats in NY who happen to be Jewish- do you feel safer today? That is unacceptable in 2026 . WTF are you doing voting for democrats ?

Steven S. Lamb's avatar

Tucker Carlson is very simply a whore. When Putin gave him some money he went to Russia. "Russia is a wonderland" He declared. Then Qatar gave him money. He bought a estate there and "Israel bad". Tomorrow if BiBi gave him some money he would be a raging Zionist. He doesn't want to be a Republican anymore? Well good. We are not a party of street walkers.

Dutchmn007's avatar

Here’s the thing: Israel has - & always will be - an ally. Our best in the region. However, certain factions label any criticism of Israel as “anti-Semitic”; that isn’t fair, any - & every - ally is fair game for criticism. It’s the govt being criticized not the people. Personally I always liked Bibi Netanyahu; not an expert on him but I know he’s an IDF veteran & Israeli patriot. I respect that. I know he’s been banging the “Iran will have a nuclear weapon within weeks” for 20yrs or more. Overblown? Perhaps but I don’t know for certain, I’m not in on the intel briefings he & Trump receive. However, Iran is on record: when they get a nuke they are going to drop it right in the middle of downtown Tel Aviv & also get one into NYC/Long Beach. Sticking a dirty nuke in a shipping container with a digital timer is not a hard thing to do anymore. So - due to their stated intent & demonstrated intransigence over this issue - the mad mullahs invited this war.

If they’d come clean - which they won’t- everyone could go home happy. However without regime change we’re always going to be barking up the same tree. But we’ve already gone down that “regime change” road & it’s fraught with one disaster after another.

As far as the growing anti-Semitism of the Dem party, anymore the Dem party is a loose confederation of special interest groups working @ cross purposes of each other; the Muslims will not tolerate the Jews or the gays or the feminists.

But apparently they can’t see that.

Sandra Pinches's avatar

Iran might not want to bomb NYC now that they have a Muslim ally running the city. But it's hard to know, given that the 9/11 terrorists had no qualms about killing the Muslims who worked at the World Trade Center (or anywhere else the terrorists chose to attack).

Dutchmn007's avatar

They’re all cogs in a machine to be expended for “just cause” in their worldview. A good example of this is The Red Army during World War II; Soviet commanders would attack German positions in relentless human wave assaults, one after another after another. It never mattered how many men they lost, only that they would break through the German line. Stalin knew he had an inexhaustible supply of manpower & he used it in profligate fashion. The Germans inflicted about a half dozen Stalingrad-size defeats on The Red Army - the Izyum Bulge was even larger, forcing over 600,000 Soviet troops to surrender - but there was always another hundred thousand men in reserve to throw into the meat grinder. And the Soviet troops had NKVD -forerunner of the KGB - security battalions behind the advancing troops to shoot on sight any shirkers. Col Douglas MacGregor has referred to The Red Army as “an army of slaves” & that observation is absolutely spot on. To compare: the U.S. lost about 430,000 Killed in Action entirely in the war; the Soviets lost over 300,000 men taking Berlin alone.

I digress but my point is the individual is nothing to them; simply a pawn to be moved about the chessboard & discarded when used up.

Diana Murray's avatar

Good analysis of the DSA earthquake but bad on Carlson.

Carlson is now free to be a rogue node. He's the right wing version of a fellow traveler.

Three Big Lies's avatar

Tucker Carlson is doing immeasurable damage to the young coalition that helped win the 2024 election.

Liora Jacob's avatar

My concern is that in the longer term those on the regressive left and woke Reich will eventually coalesce around their hatred for Jews and decide to start a new political party, sidelining both moderate Democrats and establishment Republicans, with Carlson at the head - with so many prominent people this could really gain traction and by 2040 you have a firmly established new IslamoNazi party in the White House.

Don’t forget the Nazis did not need majority German support to gain control of the country - and eventually of Europe.

H.S.'s avatar

Here we go again! You made the phrase “antisemitism” utterly meaningless. Americans do NOT want to fund the war machine of a wealthy foreign country, which enables them to fund their social services while Americans lack these services. It is a righteous call.

Hugo Davis's avatar

Girl, you dumb

PETER SALTZMAN's avatar

No doubt the left is far worse, Batya, but I think this may be wishful and selective thinking regarding the right. Either way, we’re getting it from both sides now (not to quote Joni Mitchell) and we may have some decisions to make soon about the viability of our presence here in America. I still believe Americans as a whole don’t buy into this shit, but the parties have been taken over by extremists.

Steenroid's avatar

I for one don’t. I’m not Jewish but I’m smart enough to know there is no such thing as Palestine.

Richard's avatar

OK, I largely agree but this is not why I came here. I was looking for perspective that you seem uniquely positions to provide. The issue of populist fusion animates me and I thought you.